bandit wrote:AllyG wrote:Bandit,
I do agree with you (because muscle weighs more than fat), but it's a good general guideline though, which is why our doctors and nurses use it. Some of the sites also include wrist circumference etc. to allow for bone size
And how many of us are built like Arnold Swartzenegger anyway? Apart from you of course :wink:
Have fun at the gym :D
Ally
It is an outdated measure, since it was developed in the mid 1800's and people are generally taller and heavier now. It does nothing to measure adipose tissue, but if your parents were big boned, you can look forward to lots of lectures about how overweight you are (even if your ribs stick out).
I imagine that the NHS uses it, because it's free, and they can put it on their computers, thereby removing any need to make a clinical judgement based on an examination, and allowing them to put a tick in a box.
the modern measure is fat percentage, this takes into account build, height etc and gives you a fat percentage of your overall weight. this allows for some one bein g 18 stone of pure muscle not being labelled "overweught"