blue runs - not??
Login
Following on from an issue raised in ski etiquette why on earth are so many of those runs with the narrow road section classed as blue?! I am a pretty reasoanble skier but still hate them as I am aware of the possibility than any small error could result in me lying in various size pieces 100 feet below, as evidenced by the poor guy in Alpe D'Huez this weekend.
It put my friend off skiing for life. After a very promising first day on the nursery slopes, the instructor took them up on the lift the next day and came down one of these which left the poor girl shaking for hours and a flat refusal to have any more to do with the sport!
I know skiiing is not for the faint hearted but I do think these runs need to be highlighted in some way so users can make informed decisions about the pistes they take.
Shazzo
There's some misconceptions here. The run grading isn't arbitrary, it's based on gradients so it's an absolute measure not something someone made up, the idea that an experienced skier or instructor lacks the insight into what other people might find hard doesn't really stand up either.
The accident in Alpe D'Huez is very unfortunate and not all the facts are known yet but it was identified the skier was travelling at some speed and we know from the figures that skiing is pretty safe as a rule, not only in general, but specifically on that run in that ski station there's no history of accidents. You can judge how unlikely it is that something could "result in me lying in various size pieces 100 feet below" by how many times it happens which is not often.
If you're with an instructor then that's different, they shouldn't take you anywhere there's absolute risk and if they are they are at fault. But they should take you places where there's perceived and actual risk, one of things a beginner isn't good at is judging those differences. In outdoor ed' you reckon "no risk, no fun" :D If you're using a instructor and particularly a guide then you expect to be in that actual risk zone, it's one of the biggest things you're paying them for.
Like a lot of activities the most dangerous bit of skiing is getting there and using the roads :D
Agreed. Though, it's not the by the book classification that is the issue. It is simply idenitifying places that can freak out a beginner even though it meets all of the criteria for a "blue run". e.g. a gentle slope 4 meters wide may qualify as a blue but if you don't fence off the 2,000ft drop off the side, you will freak out the beginners. (I'm exagerating for illustration :-) ) !
My example above - where the trail crew inadvertantly created a huge ice mogul is a good example.
P.s. I'm interested - what are the criteria used in Europe. I always thought it depended on the resort?
there's an homologation, you can see the signs in places stating when it was done I think. I've no idea if the full criteria are available somewhere but I think piste grading is one of a number of items. Of course the ski company insurers will also act to ensure grading is consistent
To Create or Answer a Topic
Started by Shazzo in Ski Chatter 18-Mar-2009 - 15 Replies
Shazzo posted Mar-2009
Following on from an issue raised in ski etiquette why on earth are so many of those runs with the narrow road section classed as blue?! I am a pretty reasoanble skier but still hate them as I am aware of the possibility than any small error could result in me lying in various size pieces 100 feet below, as evidenced by the poor guy in Alpe D'Huez this weekend.
It put my friend off skiing for life. After a very promising first day on the nursery slopes, the instructor took them up on the lift the next day and came down one of these which left the poor girl shaking for hours and a flat refusal to have any more to do with the sport!
I know skiiing is not for the faint hearted but I do think these runs need to be highlighted in some way so users can make informed decisions about the pistes they take.
Shazzo
Steverandomno
reply to 'blue runs - not??' posted Mar-2009
I totally agree.
The problem is that these decisions are made by intermediate/advanced skiers who have forgotten the fear factor of being a beginner. Also, the marketing dept are likely to put a stop to any upward reclassification of a key connector that would potentialy discourage beginner skiers from choosing the resort in the first place.
I have always wondered if resorts ever employ/consult the odd beginner on their saftey crew. It might give them a unique insight into the world from their perspective.
The worst beginner unfriendly thing I have ever seen was where the trail crew had errected a big orange chicane fence (forcing skiers through a big s-turn) with the intention of slowing them down at the bottom of the hill. Unfortunately this had the effect of creating a huge ice mogul that even the most advanced were falling over. It turned a saftey feature into an potential death trap. (read in style of Lynn Faulds Wood) :)
The problem is that these decisions are made by intermediate/advanced skiers who have forgotten the fear factor of being a beginner. Also, the marketing dept are likely to put a stop to any upward reclassification of a key connector that would potentialy discourage beginner skiers from choosing the resort in the first place.
I have always wondered if resorts ever employ/consult the odd beginner on their saftey crew. It might give them a unique insight into the world from their perspective.
The worst beginner unfriendly thing I have ever seen was where the trail crew had errected a big orange chicane fence (forcing skiers through a big s-turn) with the intention of slowing them down at the bottom of the hill. Unfortunately this had the effect of creating a huge ice mogul that even the most advanced were falling over. It turned a saftey feature into an potential death trap. (read in style of Lynn Faulds Wood) :)
Edited 3 times. Last update at 18-Mar-2009
Gaz jones
reply to 'blue runs - not??' posted Mar-2009
I had a similar experience in Badhofgestein, one day on the greens and then onto a long narrow blue with the instructor, the slope was a road, heavily wooded with an almost shear drop on one side, i did'nt know the slope so I had not got a clue where the turns were in the road, it also crossed a very steep black slope so you had skiers and boarders wizzing passed you at high speed at one point. I was only able to snow plough at the time so my legs were wrecked after snow ploughing constantly for nearly two hours. i don't blame the resort because the gradient was probably blue I blame the ski instructor who should never have taken us on this slope after one day. It did put me off skiing the next day to be honest but then he took us on a very wide blue which was steeper but with a lot more room to turn and moderate your speed.
I would much rather ski on a nice wide red than a narrow blue as it is more forgiving if i make a mistake
I would much rather ski on a nice wide red than a narrow blue as it is more forgiving if i make a mistake
Ise
reply to 'blue runs - not??' posted Mar-2009
shazzo wrote:
Following on from an issue raised in ski etiquette why on earth are so many of those runs with the narrow road section classed as blue?! I am a pretty reasoanble skier but still hate them as I am aware of the possibility than any small error could result in me lying in various size pieces 100 feet below, as evidenced by the poor guy in Alpe D'Huez this weekend.
It put my friend off skiing for life. After a very promising first day on the nursery slopes, the instructor took them up on the lift the next day and came down one of these which left the poor girl shaking for hours and a flat refusal to have any more to do with the sport!
I know skiiing is not for the faint hearted but I do think these runs need to be highlighted in some way so users can make informed decisions about the pistes they take.
Shazzo
steverandomno wrote:The problem is that these decisions are made by intermediate/advanced skiers who have forgotten the fear factor of being a beginner.
There's some misconceptions here. The run grading isn't arbitrary, it's based on gradients so it's an absolute measure not something someone made up, the idea that an experienced skier or instructor lacks the insight into what other people might find hard doesn't really stand up either.
The accident in Alpe D'Huez is very unfortunate and not all the facts are known yet but it was identified the skier was travelling at some speed and we know from the figures that skiing is pretty safe as a rule, not only in general, but specifically on that run in that ski station there's no history of accidents. You can judge how unlikely it is that something could "result in me lying in various size pieces 100 feet below" by how many times it happens which is not often.
If you're with an instructor then that's different, they shouldn't take you anywhere there's absolute risk and if they are they are at fault. But they should take you places where there's perceived and actual risk, one of things a beginner isn't good at is judging those differences. In outdoor ed' you reckon "no risk, no fun" :D If you're using a instructor and particularly a guide then you expect to be in that actual risk zone, it's one of the biggest things you're paying them for.
Like a lot of activities the most dangerous bit of skiing is getting there and using the roads :D
Edited 1 time. Last update at 18-Mar-2009
Tony_H
reply to 'blue runs - not??' posted Mar-2009
I am not a fan of the blue "tracks" as I call them. These are often roads which are pisted in the winter, and usually offer nothing more than access from A to B. Yes they can be narrow, but you really have to learn to ski on all types of surfaces and width runs.
It does not mean all blues are tracks, but it probably does mean all tracks are blues. I prefer to ski reds as I prefer something with more momentum, and I obviously prefer wider reds too. But you cant always choose the type of piste you ski on.
I have found these kind of runs are often exit runs from a mountain, or links to a lift station. If you dont like them, you dont HAVE to ski them.
It does not mean all blues are tracks, but it probably does mean all tracks are blues. I prefer to ski reds as I prefer something with more momentum, and I obviously prefer wider reds too. But you cant always choose the type of piste you ski on.
I have found these kind of runs are often exit runs from a mountain, or links to a lift station. If you dont like them, you dont HAVE to ski them.
www
New and improved me
Steverandomno
reply to 'blue runs - not??' posted Mar-2009
ise wrote:
There's some misconceptions here. The run grading isn't arbitrary, it's based on gradients so it's an absolute measure not something someone made up, the idea that an experienced skier or instructor lacks the insight into what other people might find hard doesn't really stand up either.
Agreed. Though, it's not the by the book classification that is the issue. It is simply idenitifying places that can freak out a beginner even though it meets all of the criteria for a "blue run". e.g. a gentle slope 4 meters wide may qualify as a blue but if you don't fence off the 2,000ft drop off the side, you will freak out the beginners. (I'm exagerating for illustration :-) ) !
My example above - where the trail crew inadvertantly created a huge ice mogul is a good example.
P.s. I'm interested - what are the criteria used in Europe. I always thought it depended on the resort?
Edited 1 time. Last update at 18-Mar-2009
Ise
reply to 'blue runs - not??' posted Mar-2009
steverandomno wrote:
P.s. I'm interested - what are the criteria used in Europe. I always thought it depended on the resort?
there's an homologation, you can see the signs in places stating when it was done I think. I've no idea if the full criteria are available somewhere but I think piste grading is one of a number of items. Of course the ski company insurers will also act to ensure grading is consistent
LM
reply to 'blue runs - not??' posted Mar-2009
Im not sure if it is the same over there but here in Canada it goes:
Green (easiest)
Blue (intermediate)
Black diamond (difficult,steep)
double black diamond (experts only)
"steverandomno wrote:The problem is that these decisions are made by intermediate/advanced skiers who have forgotten the fear factor of being a beginner"
He is right,I admit I have innocently done that to my friends..not realizing that they are really scared. :(
Green (easiest)
Blue (intermediate)
Black diamond (difficult,steep)
double black diamond (experts only)
"steverandomno wrote:The problem is that these decisions are made by intermediate/advanced skiers who have forgotten the fear factor of being a beginner"
He is right,I admit I have innocently done that to my friends..not realizing that they are really scared. :(
Topic last updated on 18-March-2009 at 20:16